All articles記事一覧全部文章

Stay or go? A recruiter's perspective on handling counteroffers

What counteroffers are, the negotiation trends behind them and how well they hold up over time. Plus the questions to ask before you decide.

残るか、去るか。リクルーターが語るカウンターオファーへの向き合い方

カウンターオファーとは何か、その背景にある交渉のトレンド、そして長期的な有効性。決断の前に考えるべき問いをまとめました。

去还是留?一位招聘顾问谈如何应对反聘

什么是反聘、背后的谈判趋势,以及它们长期的效果如何。并附上做决定前值得思考的问题。

Illustration of a person standing in a corridor between two offices, titled “STAY or GO? A Recruiter's Perspective on Handling Counteroffers”

When you receive a job offer from another company, your current employer might step in with a counteroffer to keep you on board. This could involve a bump in pay, better perks, or new growth opportunities. It's a negotiation tactic aimed at sweetening the deal to secure your talent.

Trends in Negotiation

Surveys from CareerBuilder reveal interesting trends in job offer negotiations:

  • Many candidates (56%) don't negotiate for higher pay when offered a job.
  • Over half (51%) feel uncomfortable asking for more money.
  • Nearly half (47%) worry that salary negotiations might cost them the job offer.
  • Gender disparity exists, 68% of women preferring not to negotiate compensation, compared to 52% of men.

The Double-Edged Sword of Counteroffers

While counteroffers may seem appealing, they often serve as temporary solutions. Consider these statistics:

  • 57% of counteroffer acceptees change companies within 2 years (LiveCareer research)
  • 42% of faculty who received counteroffers still departed their institutions (study on academia)

Additional considerations:

  • Accepting counteroffers can strain employer-employee trust.
  • Counteroffers often address salary but not underlying issues like culture or career progression
  • According to recent research by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), nearly half (45%) of employers believe counteroffers are effective in retaining employees for 12 months or more. However, a significant portion, almost a third (29%), finds counteroffers inefficient in keeping employees within their organization.

Moreover, accepting a counteroffer can damage your relationship with your current employer and may not address the underlying reasons for wanting to leave.

If you are torn between staying in your current role or accepting a new offer, you are not alone. It's a big decision that can significantly impact your career. Let's break down some key factors to consider:

  • Growth Opportunities: Look at the potential for advancement in both roles. Where can you learn new skills and take on more responsibilities? A new position might offer fresh challenges that could enhance your career prospects, but don't discount growth opportunities at your current company either.
  • Compensation and Benefits: It's not just about the salary, though that's certainly important. Compare the total compensation packages, including benefits and perks. Use salary comparison websites like Glassdoor or PayScale to get a sense of market rates. If you're in Japan, local options like Project COMP, Openwork, and Openmoney can be helpful.
  • Long-Term Career Vision-Strategic Planning: Consider your career two steps ahead. Think about where you want to be in a few years. If staying put means limited change in your profile, consider whether the new role aligns better with your long-term goals. Remember, frequent job changes can provide diverse experiences, but they can also impact long-term progression if you jump ship too often. On the flip side, staying in the same company for too long can also be less than ideal, as it can limit your exposure to new challenges and industry practices which can also mean hitting your career plateau. It's important to find the balance and cadence on when to switch.

A counteroffer may seem tempting when your employer offers you just what you need or even more than you expected. However, it often doesn't fix what's really bothering you about your job. Before you jump at one, take a step back and think about what you want from your career. And keep in mind, accepting a counteroffer could throw a wrench in future raises or promotions at your current company.

At the end of the day, your decision should line up with where you want to go professionally and what matters most to you. It might be worth grabbing coffee with an experienced recruiter to get their take. They can help you sort through your options and make a call that will set you up for success down the road.

When you receive a job offer from another company, your current employer might step in with a counteroffer to keep you on board. This could involve a bump in pay, better perks, or new growth opportunities. It's a negotiation tactic aimed at sweetening the deal to secure your talent.

Trends in Negotiation

Surveys from CareerBuilder reveal interesting trends in job offer negotiations:

  • Many candidates (56%) don't negotiate for higher pay when offered a job.
  • Over half (51%) feel uncomfortable asking for more money.
  • Nearly half (47%) worry that salary negotiations might cost them the job offer.
  • Gender disparity exists, 68% of women preferring not to negotiate compensation, compared to 52% of men.

The Double-Edged Sword of Counteroffers

While counteroffers may seem appealing, they often serve as temporary solutions. Consider these statistics:

  • 57% of counteroffer acceptees change companies within 2 years (LiveCareer research)
  • 42% of faculty who received counteroffers still departed their institutions (study on academia)

Additional considerations:

  • Accepting counteroffers can strain employer-employee trust.
  • Counteroffers often address salary but not underlying issues like culture or career progression
  • According to recent research by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), nearly half (45%) of employers believe counteroffers are effective in retaining employees for 12 months or more. However, a significant portion, almost a third (29%), finds counteroffers inefficient in keeping employees within their organization.

Moreover, accepting a counteroffer can damage your relationship with your current employer and may not address the underlying reasons for wanting to leave.

If you are torn between staying in your current role or accepting a new offer, you are not alone. It's a big decision that can significantly impact your career. Let's break down some key factors to consider:

  • Growth Opportunities: Look at the potential for advancement in both roles. Where can you learn new skills and take on more responsibilities? A new position might offer fresh challenges that could enhance your career prospects, but don't discount growth opportunities at your current company either.
  • Compensation and Benefits: It's not just about the salary, though that's certainly important. Compare the total compensation packages, including benefits and perks. Use salary comparison websites like Glassdoor or PayScale to get a sense of market rates. If you're in Japan, local options like Project COMP, Openwork, and Openmoney can be helpful.
  • Long-Term Career Vision-Strategic Planning: Consider your career two steps ahead. Think about where you want to be in a few years. If staying put means limited change in your profile, consider whether the new role aligns better with your long-term goals. Remember, frequent job changes can provide diverse experiences, but they can also impact long-term progression if you jump ship too often. On the flip side, staying in the same company for too long can also be less than ideal, as it can limit your exposure to new challenges and industry practices which can also mean hitting your career plateau. It's important to find the balance and cadence on when to switch.

A counteroffer may seem tempting when your employer offers you just what you need or even more than you expected. However, it often doesn't fix what's really bothering you about your job. Before you jump at one, take a step back and think about what you want from your career. And keep in mind, accepting a counteroffer could throw a wrench in future raises or promotions at your current company.

At the end of the day, your decision should line up with where you want to go professionally and what matters most to you. It might be worth grabbing coffee with an experienced recruiter to get their take. They can help you sort through your options and make a call that will set you up for success down the road.

When you receive a job offer from another company, your current employer might step in with a counteroffer to keep you on board. This could involve a bump in pay, better perks, or new growth opportunities. It's a negotiation tactic aimed at sweetening the deal to secure your talent.

Trends in Negotiation

Surveys from CareerBuilder reveal interesting trends in job offer negotiations:

  • Many candidates (56%) don't negotiate for higher pay when offered a job.
  • Over half (51%) feel uncomfortable asking for more money.
  • Nearly half (47%) worry that salary negotiations might cost them the job offer.
  • Gender disparity exists, 68% of women preferring not to negotiate compensation, compared to 52% of men.

The Double-Edged Sword of Counteroffers

While counteroffers may seem appealing, they often serve as temporary solutions. Consider these statistics:

  • 57% of counteroffer acceptees change companies within 2 years (LiveCareer research)
  • 42% of faculty who received counteroffers still departed their institutions (study on academia)

Additional considerations:

  • Accepting counteroffers can strain employer-employee trust.
  • Counteroffers often address salary but not underlying issues like culture or career progression
  • According to recent research by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), nearly half (45%) of employers believe counteroffers are effective in retaining employees for 12 months or more. However, a significant portion, almost a third (29%), finds counteroffers inefficient in keeping employees within their organization.

Moreover, accepting a counteroffer can damage your relationship with your current employer and may not address the underlying reasons for wanting to leave.

If you are torn between staying in your current role or accepting a new offer, you are not alone. It's a big decision that can significantly impact your career. Let's break down some key factors to consider:

  • Growth Opportunities: Look at the potential for advancement in both roles. Where can you learn new skills and take on more responsibilities? A new position might offer fresh challenges that could enhance your career prospects, but don't discount growth opportunities at your current company either.
  • Compensation and Benefits: It's not just about the salary, though that's certainly important. Compare the total compensation packages, including benefits and perks. Use salary comparison websites like Glassdoor or PayScale to get a sense of market rates. If you're in Japan, local options like Project COMP, Openwork, and Openmoney can be helpful.
  • Long-Term Career Vision-Strategic Planning: Consider your career two steps ahead. Think about where you want to be in a few years. If staying put means limited change in your profile, consider whether the new role aligns better with your long-term goals. Remember, frequent job changes can provide diverse experiences, but they can also impact long-term progression if you jump ship too often. On the flip side, staying in the same company for too long can also be less than ideal, as it can limit your exposure to new challenges and industry practices which can also mean hitting your career plateau. It's important to find the balance and cadence on when to switch.

A counteroffer may seem tempting when your employer offers you just what you need or even more than you expected. However, it often doesn't fix what's really bothering you about your job. Before you jump at one, take a step back and think about what you want from your career. And keep in mind, accepting a counteroffer could throw a wrench in future raises or promotions at your current company.

At the end of the day, your decision should line up with where you want to go professionally and what matters most to you. It might be worth grabbing coffee with an experienced recruiter to get their take. They can help you sort through your options and make a call that will set you up for success down the road.

More articlesその他の記事更多文章
Market entry & insights市場参入 & インサイト市场进入与洞察Balancing tradition and modernity in Japan’s employee benefits伝統と革新のあいだで考える、日本の福利厚生在传统与现代之间,聊聊日本的员工福利Insurance, leave and increments, plus the non-traditional provisions that help companies in Japan stay competitive and retain people for the long term.保険、休暇、昇給。そして日本で競争力を保ち、長期的な定着を支える新しい福利厚生のかたち。保险、休假与加薪,以及帮助日本企业保持竞争力、留住人才的新型福利。 Market entry & insights市場参入 & インサイト市场进入与洞察Navigating Japan's super-aging society超高齢社会・日本をどう読み解くか如何应对日本的超高龄社会In 2023, 29.1% of Japan's residents were 65 or older. What the world's oldest population means for the economy, healthcare and the labour market.2023年、日本の65歳以上の人口は29.1%に。世界一の高齢社会が経済、医療、労働市場にもたらす課題と機会。2023年,日本65岁及以上人口占29.1%。全球最高龄的社会对经济、医疗和劳动力市场意味着什么。 Hiring strategy採用戦略招聘策略Employer branding trends that actually work for hiring in Japan日本の採用で本当に効く、エンプロイヤーブランディング真正适用于日本招聘的雇主品牌趋势Which employer branding trends translate to Japan and how to align them with the country's social, work and cultural norms.どのトレンドが日本で通用するのか。日本の社会・労働・文化の規範にどう合わせるべきかを解説します。哪些雇主品牌趋势在日本行得通,以及如何与日本的社会、职场和文化规范相契合。
Start a search採用のご相談开始招聘

Got a hire that can’t go wrong? 失敗できない採用が、ありますか。 有一个绝不能出错的招聘?

Tell us about the role. We’ll come back with a strategy to find the right person and win them. ポジションについてお聞かせください。最適な人材を見つけ、確実に採用するための戦略をご提案します。 说说这个职位吧。我们会拿出一套方案,帮您找到合适的人,并把他请进来。